On eBay
As an eBay Partner, I may be compensated if you make a purchase
Series
My Love Story 5
Charlton Tales
Curated Charlton tales, timelines, and cover art notes.
Market Pricing
View Full Market Prices
How much is My Love Story #5 worth?
Current market pricing for My Love Story #5 shows a latest graded sale of CGC 4.5 sold for $84 on July 19th, 2021.
Graded price ranges include CGC 4.5 $84 (1 comp).
Pricing data last updated June 28th, 2026.
- Cover Date
- December 1956
- Cover Titles
- When A Girl's In Love!
Never Let Me Go! - Cover Credits
-
Vince Colletta pencils signed
Issue Overview
My Love Story #5 was published in December 1956. It is part of the My Love Story series, which ran from April 1956 to August 1957.
Cover credits include Vince Colletta.
Atlas Tales indexes 6 stories for this issue, including "Darling, Be Mine!." Indexed story credits include Vince Colletta and Tom Scheuer, among others.
Stories
Darling, Be Mine!
Never Let Me Go!
Side By Side
Happy Ending
When a Girl's In Love!
Market Pricing
Graded Price Ranges
Featured eBay Matches
View Sold Comps (1)
Looking for the full run? Browse the My Love Story checklist to see every indexed issue in one place.