On eBay

As an eBay Partner, I may be compensated if you make a purchase

Searching eBay…
Charlton Tales icon

Series

My Love Story 5

Charlton Tales

Title Profile

Curated Charlton tales, timelines, and cover art notes.

Published April 1956 – August 1957
Issue Numbers 1 – 9
Total Issues 9

Market Pricing

View Full Market Prices

How much is My Love Story #5 worth? Current market pricing for My Love Story #5 shows a latest graded sale of CGC 4.5 sold for $84 on July 19th, 2021.
Graded price ranges include CGC 4.5 $84 (1 comp).
Pricing data last updated June 28th, 2026.

My Love Story #5 (1956) | Charlton Tales Cover Image
Issue Information
Cover Date
December 1956
 
Cover Titles
When A Girl's In Love!
Never Let Me Go!
 
Cover Credits
Vince Colletta pencils signed

Issue Overview

My Love Story #5 was published in December 1956. It is part of the My Love Story series, which ran from April 1956 to August 1957.

Cover credits include Vince Colletta.

Atlas Tales indexes 6 stories for this issue, including "Darling, Be Mine!." Indexed story credits include Vince Colletta and Tom Scheuer, among others.

Stories

Market Pricing

Last Updated 2026-06-28 08:35:03
Last Graded Sale CGC 4.5 sold for $84 on July 19th, 2021
Reported Sources Heritage Auctions

Graded Price Ranges

CGC 4.5 $84 (1 comp)
View Sold Comps (1)
Grade
Price
Date
Source
Link
4.5
$84
July 19th, 2021
Heritage Auctions

Looking for the full run? Browse the My Love Story checklist to see every indexed issue in one place.