On eBay

As an eBay Partner, I may be compensated if you make a purchase

Searching eBay…
  1. Titles
  2. My Love Story
  3. My Love Story #1 (1956) | Charlton Tales
Charlton Tales icon

Series

My Love Story 1

Charlton Tales

Title Profile

Curated Charlton tales, timelines, and cover art notes.

Published April 1956 – August 1957
Issue Numbers 1 – 9
Total Issues 9
View Checklist Market Pricing

Market Pricing

View Full Market Prices

How much is My Love Story #1 worth? Current market pricing for My Love Story #1 shows a latest graded sale of CGC 3.0 sold for $46 on July 25th, 2023.
Graded price ranges include CGC 3.0 $3 (1 comp).
Pricing data last updated June 27th, 2026.

My Love Story #1 (1956) | Charlton Tales Cover Image
View Larger Image
Issue Information
Cover Date
April 1956
 
Cover Titles
I'll Never Forget You!
Love On The Rebound!
 
Cover Credits
Jay Scott Pike pencils guess
 
Contributions
Nick Caputo: Cover Creator Credit

Issue Overview

My Love Story #1 was published in April 1956. It is part of the My Love Story series, which ran from April 1956 to August 1957.

Cover credits include Jay Scott Pike.

Atlas Tales indexes 6 stories for this issue, including "I'll Never Forget You." Indexed story credits include Vince Colletta and Jay Scott Pike, among others.

Stories

I'll Never Forget You

Credits
Vince Colletta pencils signed
Contributors:
Tom Lammers: Story Information
Job # J-23
Pages 4
Type art

Love on the Rebound

Credits
Jay Scott Pike pencils signed
Contributors:
Tom Lammers: Story Information
Job # J-34
Pages 5
Type art

Second Chance!

Credits
John Tartaglione pencils attributed
Contributors:
Tom Lammers: Story Information
Job # J-36
Pages 4
Type art

Anniversary

Credits
Credits not yet documented
Contributors:
Tom Lammers: Story Information
Job # E-869
Pages 2
Type text

Love Is Forever!

Credits
Vince Colletta pencils signed
Contributors:
Tom Lammers: Story Information
Job # H-971
Pages 5
Type art

Afraid to Marry!

Credits
Jay Scott Pike pencils signed
Contributors:
Tom Lammers: Story Information
Job # J-33
Pages 5
Type art
Notes: The splash is identical to the cover image, with the addition of foliage in the foreground and background.

Market Pricing

Last Updated 2026-06-27 07:35:05
Last Graded Sale CGC 3.0 sold for $46 on July 25th, 2023
Reported Sources Heritage Auctions (comics.ha.com)

Graded Price Ranges

CGC 3.0 $3 (1 comp)
View Sold Comps (1)
Grade
Price
Date
Source
Link
3.0
$46
July 25th, 2023
Heritage Auctions (comics.ha.com)
View
Explore More Series Gallery Series Checklist

Looking for the full run? Browse the My Love Story checklist to see every indexed issue in one place.

Home | Contact Us | Search | News | Updates