On eBay

As an eBay Partner, I may be compensated if you make a purchase

Searching eBay…
  1. Titles
  2. Captain America Comics
  3. Captain America Comics #51 (1945) | Charlton Tales
Charlton Tales icon

Series

Captain America Comics 51

Charlton Tales

Title Profile

Curated Charlton tales, timelines, and cover art notes.

Published March 1941 – September 1954
Issue Numbers 1 – 73
Total Issues 73
Continues To Captain America's Weird Tales
View Checklist Market Pricing

Market Pricing

View Full Market Prices

How much is Captain America Comics #51 worth? Current market pricing for Captain America Comics #51 shows a latest raw sale of FN- sold for $507.88 on May 13th, 2012, a latest graded sale of CGC FN/VF 7.0 sold for $4,800 on November 22nd, 2025.
Raw price ranges include Fine/Very Fine 6.0-7.5 $507.88-$6,000 (7 comps).
Graded price ranges include CGC 3.5 $780-$840 (2 comps); CGC 4.0 $403.91 (1 comp).
Pricing data last updated April 27th, 2026.

Captain America Comics #51 (1945) | Charlton Tales Cover Image
View Larger Image
Issue Information
Cover Date
December 1945
Sighted Date Stamp
Oct 16
 
Cover Credits
Alex Schomburg pencils attributed

Issue Overview

Captain America Comics #51 was published in December 1945. It is part of Captain America Comics, a superhero series that began in 1941.

Cover credits include Alex Schomburg.

Atlas Tales indexes 6 stories for this issue, including "Mystery of the Atomic Boomerang!."

Stories

Mystery of the Atomic Boomerang!

Credits
Credits not yet documented
Captain America starring
Pages 16
Type art

Killer from the Grave

Credits
Credits not yet documented
The Human Torch starring
Pages 7
Type art

Fraternity of Fat Fellows!

Credits
Credits not yet documented
Captain America starring
Pages 10
Type art

The Case of the Accusing Hand!

Credits
Credits not yet documented
Pages 1
Type art
Feature: Let's Play Detective

Manhunt

Credits
Credits not yet documented
Pages 2
Type text

The Case of the Blonde Bombshell!

Credits
Credits not yet documented
Captain America starring
Pages 10
Type art

Market Pricing

Last Updated 2026-04-27 08:21:07
Last Raw Sale FN- sold for $507.88 on May 13th, 2012
Last Graded Sale CGC FN/VF 7.0 sold for $4,800 on November 22nd, 2025
Reported Sources Heritage Auctions

Raw Price Ranges

Fine/Very Fine 6.0-7.5 $507.88-$6,000 (7 comps)

Graded Price Ranges

CGC 3.5 $780-$840 (2 comps)
CGC 4.0 $403.91 (1 comp)
CGC 5.5 $720-$2,640 (4 comps)
CGC 6.0 $1,380-$3,120 (4 comps)
CGC 6.5 $1,920 (1 comp)
CGC 7.0 $4,800-$6,000 (3 comps)
CGC 8.0 $1,553.50 (1 comp)
CGC 9.0 $1,792.50 (1 comp)
CGC 9.2 $2,629 (1 comp)
View Sold Comps (3)
Grade
Price
Date
Source
Link
FN-
$507.88
May 13th, 2012
Heritage Auctions
View
FN/VF 7.0
$4,800
November 22nd, 2025
Heritage Auctions
View
-
-
August 8th, 2021
Heritage Auctions
View
Explore More Series Gallery Series Checklist

Looking for the full run? Browse the Captain America Comics checklist to see every indexed issue in one place.

Home | Contact Us | Search | News | Updates