On eBay
As an eBay Partner, I may be compensated if you make a purchase
Series
Mystic 51
Charlton Tales
Curated Charlton tales, timelines, and cover art notes.
Market Pricing
View Full Market Prices
How much is Mystic #51 worth?
Current market pricing for Mystic #51 shows a latest raw sale of sold for $39.99 on May 27th, 2022, a latest graded sale of CGC 5.5 sold for $169 on December 18th, 2023.
Graded price ranges include CGC 5.5 $169 (1 comp).
Pricing data last updated June 28th, 2026.
- Cover Date
- September 1956
- Indicia Frequency
- monthly
- Indicia Publisher
- Classic Syndicate, Inc.
- Cover Titles
- Man in the Dark!
- Cover Credits
-
Bill Everett pencils and inks attributed
- Contributions
-
Jim Vadeboncoeur Jr.: Cover Creator Credit
Issue Overview
Mystic #51 was published by Classic Syndicate, Inc. in September 1956. It is part of the Mystic series, which ran from March 1951 to August 1957.
Cover credits include Bill Everett.
Atlas Tales indexes 7 stories for this issue, including "Man in the Dark." Indexed story credits include Lou Morales and Marvin Stein, among others. The current cover scan may need replacement.
Stories
Man in the Dark
Jim Vadeboncoeur Jr.: Creator Credit
Michaël Dewally: Story Scan
No One Will Ever Know!
Jim Vadeboncoeur Jr.: Creator Credit
Michaël Dewally: Story Scan
Think! If You Dare
Jim Vadeboncoeur Jr.: Creator Credit
Michaël Dewally: Story Scan
Behind the Door
Jim Vadeboncoeur Jr.: Creator Credit
Michaël Dewally: Story Scan
The Salesman
Wings in the Night!
Jim Vadeboncoeur Jr.: Creator Credit
Michaël Dewally: Story Scan
The Imperfect Plot
Jim Vadeboncoeur Jr.: Creator Credit
Michaël Dewally: Story Scan
Market Pricing
Graded Price Ranges
Featured eBay Matches
View Sold Comps (2)
Looking for the full run? Browse the Mystic checklist to see every indexed issue in one place.